Where the smell actually lives
A couch is not just fabric. Under the cover sit foam cushions, fiber wrap, padding, a wood frame and a thin dust cover underneath. Every day the fabric works like an air filter. It catches skin oil, sweat, cooking smells, pet dander, smoke and dust, and some of it sinks into the padding below.
Most smells come from one of five sources: body oil on the arms, headrests and seat fronts; food and drink that slipped into the crevices; pets; smoke; and moisture that turned into mildew. The surface may look clean while the smell sits in the cushion core. That is why a spray of air freshener works for an hour and then fades.
Long Island weather makes it worse. In winter the windows stay shut and the heat runs, so smells build up in the room. In summer, humid air near the harbor wakes up old odors again. If your sofa smells worse on a damp day, the source is still inside.